Why Chris Tomlin’s “Home” Is Dangerous

I love Chris Tomlin’s music.

But this song worried me.  Not because it wasn’t beautiful, because it is.  Not because musically it wasn’t well done, because it was.  Not because Tomlin has lost a step, because if anything he is as good now as he has ever been.  It’s the ambiguous message of the song that bothers me.

I believe in this amazing place waiting for us when we leave this Earth.  But I think songs like this are less about the hope we have than about the promise of something better.  I don’t think Heaven is supposed to be the reward at the end of the journey, but a part of the journey we are on with God.  I don’t think we’re supposed to sit on this Earth and pine away for the something better.  We’re supposed to be doing something.  You were created for a purpose.  You were given a gift.  All of us have within us the capacity to draw closer to God and to help others draw closer, too.  Our gifts are judged by the world as being great and small, but I believe that God values them all the same.

Heaven is the great promise, but you are needed, wanted, and loved on Earth right now.

It’s what you do with your gift while you are here on this Earth that matters the most.

What will you do with your gift?

Songs like this appeal to us because they offer a shining alternative to all that is happening on Earth.  There are some pretty awful things that happen down here.  We are sometimes really awful to each other.  And a song like this appeals to us because it offers hope for something better than this world we live in.  But that’s escapist philosophy.  “Don’t worry because there’s something better after you die.”

My other worry about this song is not just that it encourages us to wait and do nothing – but that it encourages us to leave this place before we’re done.  Someone suffering from depression would hear this song in a really different way.  Why not go to this other place now?  Why wait?  There’s nothing in the theology of this song that helps people to understand that Heaven is a hope, but that we are useful, wanted, and loved on this Earth right now.  Right now!

Do I like this song?  Yep.  But I think I would have loved it had it given us hope NOW instead of only after we die.

Twitter Facebook EmailInstagram

Advertisements

One thought on “Why Chris Tomlin’s “Home” Is Dangerous

  1. Amen, I totally agree. This song is such a comfort to me with the passing of my dad. He deserved his reward in heaven. However, the Lord’s Prayer says “thy kingdom come, thy will be done. On earth as it is in heaven” The will of God is not limited to heaven. Jesus came to break the chains and set the captives free on earth. We as christians (and if you think about it not even non Christians) have the priveledge and duty to break the chains of bondage, to speak truth and life, to heal the sick, give to the poor, perform miracles, signs and wonders until the day we meet Jesus. Each of us are given gifts that we may not even realize or know how to access. I pray that God will help us recognize and activate our gifts, talents and passions. That God will equip us to move forward. I release a shift in mindset and atmosphere in the church from what can I receive to what can I give to bring hope, life, love, and restoration. My hope is in Jesus for today and tomorrow.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s